https://www.straitstimes.com/singapore/courts-crime/uncle-found-65-liable-for-injuries-of-girl-who-was-flung-out-of-van-during-crash

SINGAPORE - An eight-year-old girl was severely injured in 2020 after being flung out of a van when a speeding car collided with it.

She had been in the van’s rear cargo compartment, which had neither seats nor seat belts.

A High Court trial was held to apportion liability between the two defendants – her uncle, who had been driving the van, and the driver of the car, Mr Vincent Chui.

In a written judgment issued on Tuesday, Judicial Commissioner Teh Hwee Hwee apportioned 65 per cent of the liability for the girl’s injuries to the uncle, and 35 per cent to Mr Chui.

The judicial commissioner said: “The first defendant was irresponsible and reckless to place an eight-year-old child in the rear cargo compartment of his van that was not meant to carry passengers.

“He also knew that the rear cargo compartment of the van was not fitted with seat belts, and that passengers travelling in his van are required to be belted.

“Although he might not have intended to do so, he was in effect betting on a safe journey and placing the plaintiff (the girl) at grave risk of serious injury, which unfortunately materialised.”

Catch up on the news that everyone’s talking about

[Sign up](javascript:;)

By signing up, I accept SPH Media's Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy as amended from time to time.

Yes, I would also like to receive SPH Media Group's marketing and promotions.

The issue of costs will be heard on another date.

The girl cannot be named as those below 18 years old are covered under the Children and Young Persons Act. Her uncle thus also cannot be named to protect her identity.

Shortly before the crash on Oct 23, 2020, the uncle was driving his niece and other passengers from a temple event near Woodlands to the girl’s home.

He made a legal U-turn in Woodlands Avenue 12 to get to Seletar Expressway.

But before the U-turn could be completed, Mr Chui’s car, which could be seen in video footage speeding along the road, collided with the van. The van spun before mounting a nearby kerb, and the girl was flung out of the vehicle.

She suffered multiple issues, including reduced higher-order language skills, inability to use her right hand functionally, and deformities in both ankles.